Did it succeed?
The debate regarding the success/failure of demonetisation drives has taken much desired newspaper space ; after the Central Bank- RBI made its annual report public. A smaller heading in Times of India, page 17 reads- “RBI got back Rs 16k cr, spent Rs. 21k cron new notes: Cong”. However, read on, “Rs16,000 crores out of demonetised notes of Rs 15,44,000 crore did not come back to RBI..”. How much spent how much earned, a research material for the economists, but what about the state of psychological contact of the main street? (31 August 2017)
Extracts from the Presidential address at All India Newspaper Editor’s Conference.1947
..The Press in India is now adjusting itself to a complete transformation of scene. Does it not seem but yesterday when we were engaged in grimly fighting the battle of National Herald and Harijan with little hope of stable success? Today, National Herald is digging its toes under ideal conditions of popularity, prestige and security and Harijan is in need of ever-increasing supplies of paper for its expanding circulation..MORE
Jawaharlal Nehru On Indian Press:
The Press if it wants freedom - which is ought to have must have some balance of mind which is seldom possesses. One cannot have it both ways. Evert freedom in this world is limited, limited not so much by law as by circumstances. We do not wish to come in the way of freedom of the Press. Personally, I am convinced of the freedom of the Press.... More
Television Channel Watch-Tracking (monitoring?) Television channels in India
Many readers gather information from newspapers about to be held events, assuming newspapers do not mislead them. Today supplement of DNA - “After hrs” (page 2) informs of a Book release (Modern Monk). “Where: Nehru Memorial Museum & Library, Motia Khan, Sadar Bazaar. New Delhi). (10 January 2017). Hang on, prestigious Nehru Memorial Museum & Library is NOT located at Motia Khan, Sadar Bazaar! A friend of SARCAJC has received an invitation card of this book release function mentions the correct address of Nehru Memorial Museum & Library! Alas, what will happen to any reader of DNA who will search for Nehru Memorial Museum & Library at Motia Khan, Sadar Bazaar, is anyone’s guess.
Advertisement in English appearing on cover page of a archival magazine in Hindi, evoking history
Silver story of Demonetisation:
When Indians are struggling with demonetisation of currency of higher denomination, its pertinent to remember silver story of demonetisation. Click to read more
South Asian Research Centre for Advertisement, Journalism & Cartoons (SARCAJC) is first Independent Research Centre in South Asia which undertakes media monitoring in the neglected area of cartoons, advertisements. We study, research, promote, acquire and preserve cartoons, advertisement in Newspapers, Journals, and Magazines that constitute rich cultural heritage of this vast region.Aim for news archives & museum
Recommended- Humourous story with cartoon on Demonetisation. To view click
Above archival advertisement comes with the tagline- German General. This Medicine Advertisement cites claims cure for eyes that German hospitals had termed as incurable. This domestic advertisement from Mumbai has highlighted foreign medical treatment, dubious or not, leave it to the readers.
According to INTUTE- “South Asian Research Centre for Advertisement, Journalism & Cartoons (SARCAJC) is South Asia's first study centre for research into the history and political importance of cartoons, political satire, advertisements and journalism..”.
The Hindu on page 15 carries a news report from Press Trust of India- “Centre clears 26% strategic sale in BEML”. Times of India on page 27 carries a news report procured from agencies-“Govt clears sale of 26% in defence co BEML” (7 January 2017). They inform that out of government’s holding of 54.03%, 26% stake will be sold. And this might fetch Rs. 10 billion. But hang on, isn’t BEML catering to Indian defence sector and is indeed a profitable company? Just to remind, according to Disinvestment Commission, government stake in BEML cannot be diluted, in national interest. Read MORE
ARCHIVAL SATIRE ON HOLI
,,,,,If today Shivshambu and his friends carrying colours, picharis wish to play Holi with the Raja at his house, where should they go? The Rajas is across seven seas and they have only heard his name. Shivshambu has not seen the Rajas nor has the Raja seen Shivshambu. Never mind, Raja has sent his representative to India.....READ MORE
Advertisement Watch: Poor translation looms a government advertisement. Know more
Women Unsafe in India
Anniversaries come and go, with little impact on daily lives? Shivani Singh, an intern with The Hindu reports on page 3, the anguish of mother of Nirbhaya- “ Four years have passed since we lost our daughter…Even after intense protests & appeals for my daughter’s case, she has not received justice…What can one expect for the millions of girls and women who have been similarly wronged..” (17/12/2016). The heading of this news report needs no explanation- “Nirbhaya’s death didn’t change anything”. On the same date, Times of India devoted one full page to this issue. The editorial of Times of India on 19/12/2016 came up with heading- “Unsafe City” and highlighted- “Four years after the Nirbhaya gang rape, crimes against women are going unpunished”. However, none of the newspapers or television channels have started a campaign to make city safe for women. SARCAJC has been raising issue of women insecurity regularly. Will Prime Minister Modi implement & monitor ‘Woman Safe Drive’ like the ongoing Demonetisation drive?
The first day of February 2017; majority television channels have faithfully carried the telecast of annual budget and the post budget dissections with experts. However, what is surprising is drought of female experts. The absolute male dominance raises question about reason for marginalization of females experts, specially in area of social science (read economics) in India. Zee TV utilised the surroundings of Central park in Connaught Place with all male panel. The only silver lining was presence of female anchors in some channels. But were they all well equipped with research in social sciences, remains a bone of contention. Of the channels scanned till 5:30pm, none raised questions like- why no incentives were provided for organic farming, why no incentives came in for controlling acute pollution- both affect health of the main street.
Is self regulation working effectively across all private channels? Today, (15 January 2017) in channel- News Nation, a adult category advertisement appeared four times during one hour this afternoon. What will be its impact on children who watched this television channel with their parents on this Sunday afternoon, is anyone's guess?
Today, Rajya Sabha television focused on Rabindranath Tagore in programme- Virasat during 1:30-2:00 pm (15 January 2017). During which, it remembered Mahatma Gandhi and asserted that Tagore was the first person to address Gandhi as Mahatma. While ABP News at 1:35pm highlighted in Hindi-“Gandhi ka chemical locha” and asked questions like- “Bapu desh ke kiye hanikarak hai?” (Is Bapu harmful to nation?). A contrast indeed!
Since November last year, demonetisation has dominated the Indian news channels. Some channels like India Today, ABP News showed sting operations. The Minister of Finance, Mr. Arun Jailey, while addressing a Press Conference on 30 December 16 voiced that TV channels should show queues that exist on 30 December 2016, not that existed on 10 November. There was no rebuff from the journalists present in the live Press Conference! Now with the television channels getting a lot of dramatic news regarding feud in a political party, the focus on woes of demonetisation seems to have faded from majority of prime time discussions. A few channels like Times Now did focus on instances of misbehaviour with women in Bangalore. But the bigger issue of women insecurity in India seemed missing. With today’s announcement of elections in many Indian States, again the focus will be on politics till result announcement in March?
OPPS- Yesterday, on Lok Sabha television, programme- Kaal Samvad, during a discussion on freedom fighter Gokhale, the photograph shows was that of Bal Gangadhar Tilak! (4 January 2017)
What ails Doordarshan
Amrita Nayak Dutta reported in DNA (19 December 2016) that government is planning to appoint a private firm to revitalise loss making public broadcaster- Doordarshan & bring it par with private television channels. Today (20 December 2016), DD News presented new schedule of popular programmes. Will the new schedule work without content makeover? Team SARCAJC looked at various programes in various television channels related to News from 5:10 pm. ABP News was asking-“Where all cash seized?”. While NDTV carried views of Finance Minister- Arun Jaitley and was accepting that during this demonetisation drive, some employees have misconducted. Taal Thok Ke- a debate was airing in Zee News with Rohit as anchor with 4 debaters- 3 from political parties and one Professor from Punjab University. The topic of discussion was result of Municipal result of Chandigarh elections. The channel calls this show as “Debate’s number one show”. The debate at New 24 featured 6 debaters arguing on -”Whether Shariyat courts should be closed?”. Vineet Malhotra was the anchor in the programme on current issue with 3 participants from political parties. Times Now carried a special broadcast -“I didn’t vote for this”. India Today showed an advertisement on Black money. CNN News 18, carried breaking news- “Corporate War now legal battle..Mistry moves National Company Law Tribunal”. At 5:30pm, India 24x7 asked-“which actress ruled the year 2016” but with a photograph of Union Minister- Riju! While News X carried under “Crime & City” clip of “Haryana Police Brutality”. While DD National channel educated on how to maintain lemon tree, how to grow mashroom and DD News carried Sports News. Which is more interesting, viewers decide, right?
Tappu asks Jethalal Gada, his father, the most important question ( both are characters from TV serial based on his writings- Tarak Mehta ka ulta chashma (Tarak Mehta's upside down spectacle)
Compensating the polluter?
The air pollution in Delhi has been alarming. Today (7 March 2017) , advertisement by Delhi Pollution Control Committee, Government of N.C.T of Delhi has been published in Times of India under heading-”Public Notice”. To read
Self regulation working?
Hindu has reported-“Set up mechanism to hear plaints about TV content: SC”. The legal corresponded informed-“The Supreme Court on Thursday asked the government to set up, streamline and publicise a complaint redressal mechanism…to deal with citizen’s complaints about content telecast or aired by private TV channels and radio..”. The para four of this news report carries a quote by the bench of Supreme Court-”We cannot ask the (the Centre) to monitor the content of the channels. How can we do that? ..” While Times of India’s Dhananjay Mahapatra has highlighted-”SC: Set up body to look into complaints against channels”. (13 January 2017).
SARCAJC is independently monitoring!
Today, most newspapers in Hindi have celebrated Holi- the festival of fun & colours on their masthead. The outstanding masthead with an interesting toon has been carried by Dainik Jagran- Modi & Shah playing Holi with opposition leaders. The hang-over of unprecedented wins is obvious! Dainik Bhaskar, perfumed newspaper, has carried 4 innovative toons by cartoonist- Ismil Lahari on its front page with heading- “No negative holi but positive-toon”. Talking about surprise gift on Holi- Hindi newspaper- Navbharat Times takes it all, with front & inner page carrying not only fake news but also appealing advertisements with strong dose of satire-realism, for example fake currency, fugitive with massive outstanding loans, anti-corruption satellite, penalty for late delivery of flats, mandatory aadhaar for social media, plan for growing potato & onion on moon, lift in Qutub Minar etc ! A must to read and indeed, a collector’s issue! However, this fun spirit of Holi seems absent from majority of newspaper in English, wonder why? (13 March 2017)
What is POLICY?
Extracts from Oudh Punch 1870s
Building Castles in the air; the pretense of conferring a favour upon another while promoting one’s own interest; smearing one’s body with blood & representing oneself as having fought in a religious war (i.e. to try to acquire fame by merely pretending to have taken a part in a good action); an ultimate clamour....More
The celebration of new year was visible in many newspapers. The most unique initiative was taken by Hindi newspaper- Dainik Bhaskar, which printed the paper with special ‘perfumed’ ink. Indeed the newspaper smelled well, as this special issue was named -”Success & happiness issue”. The paper also carried 12 simple, small but real cartoons on what might make you happy! While other newspapers like Dainik Jagran, Rashtriya Sahara, Loksatta, Hindustan, Navbharat Times, Dainik Tribune, Amar Ujala, Hindustan Times, Times of India have celebrated new year on their masthead, However some newspapers like Jansatta, DNA, Mail Today and Tribune preferred to be normal. Of course the best advertisement on this occasion has been that by national carrier- Air India with the punch line - “Dil mein India…Aasman mein Air India”. (India in heart, India in sky). The cartoon in Mail Today shows 2016 as old woman while cartoon in Times of India shows 2016 as old man. Which one is more real, take a clue from page 20 in Tribune which declares-“2016: The year of women power”. Some detailed feature report on women safety? Nope, but the newspaper devoted two full pages to carry reports and photos on “Punjab Assembly elections-1985” in its supplement.
(1 January 2017).
Opps: The headline”of a news report by Kaunain Sheriff M reads-”11-year-old boy with blood cancer treated for TB for a month: Docs”. However the contents reveal that age of boy is six year .(1 January 2017)
Strengthening Democracy, Governance & Accountability
The front page of Times of India informs of a study by premier government funded medical research institute in India- AIIMS about risk from mobile phones and that- “Industry-funded research plays down risk from mobiles: Study”. Yes, radiation from mobile phones is harmful. Indeed extremely alarming news for the main street who have become accustomed to this device. However, result of this study did not make it to three major newspapers in Hindi- Amar Ujala, Dainik Bhaskar and Dainik Jagran, wonder why? (6 March 2017). SARCAJC has been raising this issue for benefit of main street. TO READ- MOBILE PHONE MENACE
We really miss the vibrant tradition in Hindi journalism of 20th century == publication of supplement in form of a magazine on occasion of Holi, Diwali & Dusherra. However, Bengal, Maharashtra are still carrying on well...
Just edit this element to add your own HTML.
SARCAJC has been raising the issue of dubious advertisement that appear in newspapers. View here. Today, an advertisement by Indian Navy has appeared in English in Times of India with heading in bold- “Employment is Indian Navy- Beware of Agents/cheats”. The advertisement starts off- “It has come to the notice that some agents/touts/unsocial elements on pretext to provide employment in the Indian Navy, make upbeat promises about chances of employment….to achieve their end, they use dubious advertisements…to deceive unsuspecting job seekers…”. (11 January 2017). However, the advertisement does not inform where main street can complaint against such dubious advertisements.
Cartoons from our Cartoonist on New Year 2017!
The news that South Delhi Municipal Corporation will be setting up a biogas plant is so very important that DNA has published it twice? Today, on page 4, a news heading reads-”Biogas plant to treat dung and kitchen waste to be set up soon” and on page 15, a news reads-”Dung kitchen waste to power S Delhi biogas plant”. They both are procured from news agency- PTI and read on - word to word the same, only the heading and accompanying photograph is different. (16 January 2017)
Archival Advertisement of a Hindi movie appeared in English language
Time not important?
The world book fair in Delhi has received fair amount of publicity via advertisements. Today, an advertisement in Hindi has appeared in Hindi newspaper- Amar Ujala. The advertisement also carries- “Today’s highlights” under which it lists events (talk, book release, discussions, poet meet, dance meet the author & reading session) that will be held today in various Hall numbers, but for reasons best known does not carry the timing! Does the advertisement expect the book fair visitors to remain waiting for the event to happen from morning to evening? (12 January 2017)
IN the NEWS- AIR INDIA PRIVATISATION:
The newly released Economic Survey has called for Privatisation of Air India. Newspapers have carried this news, but where is the meat? Is just privatisation cure for all, must ask debt ridden private sector airlines- Kingfisher, due to which higher end officers of IDBI Bank are in jail?
Flash from Past: READ on - SARCAJC had raised voice: ...The ownership of an organization per se has nothing to do with its efficiency. READ MORE
Also view Map placement Goof up
The editorial of Day is being carried by DNA- “Expose the willful defaulters!” . The editorial does not mince words about unwillingness of Reserve Bank of India to reveal names of loan defaulters and also lack of will to tackle the non performing assets. Read on- "…The RBI’s chary attitude to willful defaulters is untenable…But today the biggest danger is of banks failing because of the huge percentage of bad loans on their books. Merely, writing off the loans to clean the books and start on a fresh slate is no solution either…”. 6 January 2017. However, the question of accountability of the Reserve Bank of India in failing to fulfill its responsibility as the Central Bank has not been visited , not to forget the role of leading economists at high places enjoying life. Read MORE
20 March 2016:
One glace on cartoon by our cartoonist and you can get a feel of the media coverage during cricket competition T-20 World Cup for men & women. Why are women neglected in coverage by enlightened correspondents?
JOURNALISM IN INDIA- read an article from Benares Magazine- Feb 1849. "Peculiarities of Indian Society".
.......Team SARCAJC went to check SAR ratings on various leading brands of mobile instruments, but the sales people were totally ignorant about SAR rating. The “attractive “packing box of mobile phones did not carry any SAR rating, so first buy it and then check in accompanying brochure! But majority of customers who were buying mobile phones didn’t know anything about SAR rating. ....(6 MARCH 2011) . READ MORE
Archival advertisements reveal the trends of their time. Take for instance, the following archival Hindi movie advertisement, for the movie in Hindi appears in three languages- English, Hindi, Urdu. The lead actress occupies the ad space with prominence. This is quite unlike recent Hindi movies ads where the hero takes it all!
Today, famous Indian writer, columnist, humorist - Mr. Tarak Mehta passed away in Ahmadabad, at the age of 87 years. SARCAJC pays homage to Mr. Tarak Mehta. The comedy television serial based on his writing- Tarak Mehta ka Ulta chashma’ has been extremely popular among all age groups of viewers & writings in Chitralekha magazine. He had penned down 80 books and was awarded with Padma Sri- an award by Indian government “for distinguished service” during 2015. “The award seeks to recognize works of distinction and is given for distinguished and exceptional achievements/service in all fields of activities/disciplines”. Is it off tangent that one should acknowledge/recognize accomplishments of person of eminence at prime time of writing so to encourage him/her to climb more peaks of achievements? If lobbying the only way to get what one deserves at the prime time, then it is a sad - ‘Made in India’. (1March 2017)
It is not often that one views any advertisement by Reserve Bank of India (RBI) in a newspaper in Hindi. Today, an advertisement in English has appeared in a Hindi newspaper- Dainik Bhaskar on page 9 with headline- “Reserve Bank of India. Mumbai. Notice (published as advertisement)”.Will all readers of Hindi newspaper able to read & comprehend advertisement in English? CLICK TO READ MORE.
Advertisement: Sale or compulsion?
During this time of the year, advertisements offering attractive discounts lure customers to buy, nothing unusual. However on first day of the year, the last page (18) of Hindi Newspaper- Hindustan carries an advertisement which is rather unique. The advertisement in Hindi starts off with a claim-- "For the first time in history of Delhi such low prices sale" And line below it highlights-"Due to fight between two brothers 12 showroom closed"., In bold more is unique-"The inbound split...loot of world". The advertisement goes on to list prices of garments and the addresses of 7 sale points in Delhi. How far is the claim of this advertisement true, is just a guess! (1 January 2017)
Today (20 December 2016), a full page advertisement in colour by VISA on the last page of Times of India has appeared with punch line-”Visa is helping bridge generations”. This advertisement carries a photograph of a middle aged man with a young boy showing him a mobile phone. It seems this advertisement has take clue from Indian Prime Minister’s appeal to the young generation to help by teaching the older generation to use mobile phone for cashless transactions! The advertisement echoes in smaller font- “Reach out & teach someone to go cashless. Be a digital ambassador”. While a smaller advertisement by Times of India shows photo of a smiling woman sitting with a smiling man holding a plastic card, both are looking at the screen of a laptop. The advertisement’s punch line reads-”Why spend your marketing budgets in cash dependent markets? Advertise in markets where cash doesn’t make such a difference!”. Surely, the man & woman features in this advertisement do not seem to be advertisers. To get to the crux, read on smaller fonts- “with 60% of India’s credit card usage taking place in Mumbai, Delhi, NCR & Bangalore, demonetisation has not really inhibited spending…Advertise in metro cities…”(page 4). While Bollywood actor- Ajay Devgun stars in advertisement in many television channels promoting cashless economy, courtesy Ministry of Finance. Just to remind, earlier Ajay features in Pan Masala advertisements! Keeping with brand image?
An Investigation: Merger of Indian Banks
The merger of largest governmnet controlled bank in India- SBI with other 5 banks has taken place and the data reveals it has NOT been successful. Unlike enthusiatic lead economists, media, SARCAJC had raised serious apprehension . To Read
Mahatma Gandhi on Advertisements:
I hold that it is wrong to conduct newspapers by the aid of...immortal advertisements, I do believe that if advertisements should be taken at all there should be a rigid censorship instituted by newspaper proprietors and editors themselves and that only healthy advertisements should be taken...More
The heading of news report on Page 3 of Amar Ujala shouts- “Non cheating staff of Amity School protest” with accompanying photo of women raising hands behind a banner. Non cheating staff in Amity school in Gurugram, does it mean cheating staff exist in this school !? Read on the report- non cheating becomes non teaching! (1 March 2017)
Today, two different advertisement by Government of India have appeared in Hindi in Hindi newspapers- Amar Ujala & Dainik Bhaskar informing about Sovereign Gold Bonds. The advertisement in Amar Ujala emphasizes- “With the money earned by the sweat of my bow I invested in Sovereign Gold Bond…No fear of theft & advantage galore” & is accompanied by a photograph of a family in rural setting. The ad is appealing, so what is need for another bigger advertisement in Dainik Bhaskar? This ad shows a urban man with his young daughter who is thanking her ‘Daddy’- Thank you daddy for investing in Sovereign Gold Bond for making my future bright”. Future bright of a urban small girl by investment in Gold bonds, does it anyway reflect on tradition of dowry? Surely, this advertisement was avoidable and would have saved exchequer’s money.( 1 March 2017)
An advertisement by Governmnet of NCT Delhi has appeared with heading of -"Public Notice" in Times of India regarding "Stop feeding monkeys at public places". It also informs phone numbers for lodging complaints against persons feeding monkeys at public places. (28 February 2017) However, the advertisement is silent regarding monkey menace in residential places. Did you say, humans have encroached habitat of monkeys?
15 March 2016
Today a advertisement has appeared in Times of India containing two cartoon characters- Professor and his student "Suppandi" with a question- "Did you see what happened when Suppandi met Professor simply simple yesterday?". Well, yesterday, an interesting, informative also humourous 31 page, 11 episodes, comics accompanied Times of India- "Making investing simple for Suppandi with Professor Simply Simple". A creative effort for "Investor Education" by Tata Mutual Fund. It was an advertorial and promotional feature and was created by Amar Chitra Katha, famous publisher of comic books in India.